Don't throw away the lobster shell: Simmering the shell with the vegetables and stock is one of the most important steps in this recipe. It builds a much deeper lobster flavor before the broth ever reaches the slow cooker.
Keep the cooked seafood cold: Refrigerate the lobster and crab while the broth slow cooks and add them only at the end. They're already cooked, so leaving them in the soup for hours would make them tough.
Blend before adding the cream: Get the tomato broth completely smooth first, then stir in the heavy cream and seafood. This gives you that silky bisque texture without blending up the pieces of lobster and crab.
Reheat gently: Once the cream and seafood are added, avoid boiling the bisque. Gentle heat keeps the cream smooth and the seafood tender.
Taste at the very end: Lobster, crab and Old Bay all bring saltiness to the soup, so I wait until everything is combined before deciding whether it needs more salt or seasoning.
Scan this QR code with your phone's camera to view this recipe on your mobile device.