Shamrock Shake – Irish Cream Milkshake

This shamrock shake is something pretty special! It is a St. Patrick’s shake made with Bailey’s, topped with Irish Cream infused whipped cream and crowned with some magically delicious marshmallows. You will love this Irish Cream milkshake! It is perfect for all your St. Patty’s day celebrations.

This post may contain affiliate links, please see the privacy policy for details.

This boozy shamrock shake is rich and decadent whether you tweak the recipe or make it just like I did. So enjoy every sip of your shamrock shake and have a blessed St Patrick’s Day!

Truthfully, I never had Lucky Charms cereal until I bought it recently. It wasn’t the type of cereal we ever had at home growing up.  Similar to Fruit Loops and the Rainbow Dream Squares that I made, I decided to use the Lucky Charms in a fun way. It does take a bit of time to pick the marshmallows out of the cereal, but what else do you have to do with your time?

It is worth the effort because the result is this magically delicious shamrock shake which tastes just as impressive as it looks! Serve this festive beverage in tall, thin glasses. Slim Jim type glasses would work. If you want to make smaller servings though, a martini glass would look pretty.

Lucky History of the Shamrock Shake

Have you tried a St Patrick’s shake? This green-coloured, mint-flavoured ice cream milkshake is so good. The original one was introduced by McDonalds back in 1970. These shakes are sold in February and March at some McDonalds restaurants in Canada, the US and Ireland. Interestingly the shamrock sundae was introduced a decade later, but only lasted a year due to poor sales.

This recipe is quite different from the McDonalds version though, because it is more magical! Not only did I use the ice cream, peppermint extract and green food colouring the restaurant version includes, but more too.

Why You Will Love this Irish Cream Shake

• Coffee Flavour – The combination of creamy vanilla ice cream and Irish cream liqueur creates a rich, indulgent flavour that is irresistible.
• Easy to Make – Once you have your ingredients pulled together, this drink recipe comes together quickly.
• Green Colour – It’s perfect for St. Patrick’s Day or other festive occasions.
• Boozy Milkshake – Who doesn’t love a dessert and cocktail combination?

Irish Cream Milkshake Ingredients

The Irish cream is so smooth and delicious, and goes perfectly in this St Patrick’s shake. It is whipped up with cream and icing sugar to give it a thick consistency. This allows the Lucky Charms marshmallows and sprinkles to sit on the creamy topping without falling through. You will need to use a cold metal bowl to whip the Irish cream, whipping cream and icing sugar together. You will want to form peaks with the mixture to get the right texture.

Dipping the glass into sprinkles gives the rim a pretty look. Dip the rim in lemon, lime or even orange juice. This makes the sprinkles stick to the glass. Green is the obvious colour of choice here, or you could use one of the bright colours of the marshmallows. The drink is already green. But there’s no such thing as too much green for a St Patrick’s shake!

This is a very filling ice cream milkshake, and it would also work as a dessert. Kick off the evening of St Patrick’s Day by sipping a shamrock shake after dinner. I guarantee if you’re a fan of Irish cream and peppermint you are going to love it!

Shamrock Shake Variations

There are a number of variations you could try. You can use your favourite brand of ice cream to make this. I chose a real dairy ice cream, because I prefer the taste to other ice creams. Ice cream is very much a personal choice though, so you can use whatever you happen to prefer. This Irish cream milkshake is going to be delicious as long as you use your favourite kind of ice cream. It is a treat worth looking forward to, and one of the best parts of St Patrick’s Day.

A dairy-free version of this boozy shake would work fine, and you can also use dairy free milk and cream, omitting the Irish cream too. The flavour would be different, but everyone has their own preferences and dietary needs, so make it your way. And get ready to be impressed by the result! Coffee ice cream or mint chocolate chip ice cream could be used instead of vanilla. You could add in some Creme de Menthe in addition to the coffee liqueur for another flavour option.

If you want a non-alcoholic version, you can substitute the Bailey’s for milk and the Irish Cream for vanilla extract. That way the kids can also enjoy this creamy confection. And as soon as they spot those Lucky Charms marshmallows they are sure to want some. Instead of Lucky Charms, you could use mini chocolate chips, green sprinkles or even a drizzle chocolate syrup on it instead.

So this St Patrick’s Day, get ready to go all out and impress everyone with this Bailey’s shake and more. Rustle up Irish tacos with corned beef and cabbage or Corned Beef Hash Au Gratin as your main dish. Then enjoy this St Patrick’s Day shake as dessert instead of the traditional Irish coffee.

It’s so good you’re going to want to make this Bailey’s milkshake every year from here on out! Other tasty snacks for St Patrick’s Day include shamrock cookies, Pistachio Pudding Coffee Cake and Lucky Charms Donuts. Or in fact anything green! Green is going to be your lucky colour all day.

Irish Cream Milkshake Recipe

I hope you have some fun activities planned for St. Patrick’s Day! Let me know if you try this Baileys Irish cream milkshake recipe. These lucky green milkshakes will become an annual tradition.

Other Recipes to Try

• Just like Starbucks Iced Brown Sugar Oat Milk Shaken Espresso
• Rainbow Pot O’ Gold Jello Vodka Shots
• Frosted Lucky Charms Cookies
• St. Patrick’s Cookies and Buttercream Dip
• Air Fryer Lucky Charms Marshmallow Donuts
• Gluten Free Sugar Cookies for St. Patrick’s Day