This post may contain affiliate links, please see the privacy policy for details.
What are your favorite cocktails for the fall? This toffee apple cider Fireball hot toddy has to be in my top 3! It’s a novel take on hot toddy with Fireball whiskey. The butterscotch liqueur and cinnamon whiskey blend beautifully with this hot cider cocktail. You will love the flavor of apple cider and Fireball together in this caramel apple hot toddy recipe.
You’re going to love this spiced cider. It’s really easy to make and oh those flavors! Everyone will want a second (and maybe a third) serving!
If you enjoy this tasty drink, also try bourbon peach ice cream, boozy salted peanut hot chocolate or a classic old-fashioned cocktail with bourbon.
The spiced cider is made with apple cider, cinnamon, lemon, and nutmeg. Then you will need Fireball or a similar cinnamon whiskey and butterscotch liqueur. There are plenty of optional ingredients you can take your pick from. This caramel apple hot toddy recipe is nice with a crushed toffee bit rim (use lemon juice to moisten the rim first).
Garnish this apple cider and Fireball drink with your choice of lemon and/or apple slices. A cinnamon stick and star anise also make a beautiful garnish.
How to Choose the Best Ingredients
If this hot cider cocktail is worth making (and it is!) it’s worth making well. Start off with the best ingredients and you can’t go wrong.
I like to use unfiltered apple cider for the spiced cider mixture, adding in fresh cinnamon and nutmeg as well as a freshly sliced lemon. Unfiltered apple cider is usually in the refrigerated drinks aisle or you can get it fresh from the orchard. Not everywhere carries it year-round but it’s popular around the autumn. You can always use regular apple cider when making an apple cider hot toddy if you want.
As for the butterscotch liqueur in this toffee apple cider Fireball hot toddy, you have choices. The most popular option is probably DeKuyper’s Buttershots. You will be able to find this at most liquor stores. Perhaps you have another favourite in which case use that instead. Butterscotch schnapps is another name for butterscotch liqueur.
This cocktail is made with apple cider and Fireball but you can use a Fireball alternative. There are different kinds of cinnamon whiskey including Jim Beam, Jack Daniels or Johnny Walker brands. Either choose your favourite kind of cinnamon whiskey or just pick out whatever the local liquor store has on sale.
Make an Apple Cider and Fireball Cocktail Like a Pro
Once you’re ready to make this butterscotch liqueur and cinnamon whiskey drink, you will find it easy. The first thing to do is make the spiced cider. Simmer the cider with the lemon and spices for 10 minutes. And yes, your kitchen will smell like the fall when you do this!
If you want to rim the glasses before making this caramel apple hot toddy recipe, dip them in lemon juice then in crushed toffee bits. If not, you can just omit this step. Now add the butterscotch liqueur and cinnamon whiskey. Add the spiced cider and whichever of the optional garnishes you want to use.
I love this hot toddy with Fireball whisky served hot but there is a chilled version. A cold toddy if you like, although no, it doesn’t have the same ring!
Discard the lemon slices you added to the apple cider and Fireball then put it in a pitcher and refrigerate it. It should last for up to 3 days. If you don’t fancy it cold, you can warm the apple cider back up in a pan on the stove or in the microwave.
Why This Toffee Apple Cider Fireball Hot Toddy is So Popular
This toffee apple cider Fireball hot toddy is sweet, rich and spicy. I have found a number of similar recipes but this one is extra-special.
Cinnamon whiskey is becoming ever more popular with more and more brands making their own versions. And apple cider based drinks never go out of vogue. They’re such a wonderful staple for the cooler months.
So if you’re wondering what to serve when your friends come by, you won’t go wrong with this hot cider cocktail!
Serve your toffee apple cider Fireball hot toddy in mugs. You can use clear mugs like I do or else some metal ones or any kind of heatproof glass really.
It’s a caramel apple hot toddy recipe with warm spices and plenty of delicious flavour. Warm yourself up with this sweet and cozy toffee apple cider Fireball hot toddy. It’s a breeze to make and the flavour is just so amazing.
This hot cider cocktail would go nicely with some warm appetizers. You could play it simple with a spicy corn and cheese dip or homemade smoked beef jerky. If you want something sweet, buttered zucchini muffins would be a nice seasonal appetizer. This hot toddy with Fireball whiskey is perfect for fall parties and the recipe makes enough for 6 servings.
If you are a fan of this hot toddy with Fireball whiskey, you might also like Salted Butterscotch White Russian – Fall Cocktail, Apple Pie à la Mode Cocktail with Fireball Whisky and Vanilla Vodka or Easy DIY Caramel Apples – Autumn and Halloween Treat.
Toffee Apple Cider Fireball Hot Toddy Recipe
Toffee Apple Cider Fireball Hot Toddy
Ingredients
For spiced cider (makes enough for 6 drinks):
- 8 Cups apple cider, unfiltered
- 3 cinnamon sticks
- 1/4 Tsp. ground nutmeg
- 1 lemon, sliced
For Toffee-Apple Hot Toddy:
- 1 wedge lemon, for rimming-optional
- 1/2 Cup toffee bits, for rimming-optional
- 1 Oz. schnapps, butterscotch such as DeKuyper’s Buttershots
- 2 Oz. whiskey, cinnamon such as Fireball
- 8 Oz. cider , spiced, recipe above
- Slice Apple, for garnish
- Slice Lemon , for garnish
- Star anise , for garnish
- stick cinnamon , for garnish
Instructions
For spiced cider (makes enough for 6 drinks):
- To a large pot over medium heat, add apple cider, sliced lemons, cinnamon sticks, and ground nutmeg. Stir and allow to simmer for 10 minutes. The cider will reduce by about 2 cups while taking-on the lemon, cinnamon, and nutmeg flavors. Remove from heat.
For Toffee-Apple Hot Toddy:
- Prepare a large, heat-proof mug by swiping a lemon wedge around its rim, wetting it slightly. Dip the damp rim into the finely-crushed toffee bits, making them stick.
- To the prepared mug, add butterscotch liqueur, cinnamon whisky, and spiced cider. Top with a slice of apple, a slice of lemon, a star anise pod, and a cinnamon stick. Serve hot.
Notes
Nutrition
So make this wonderful caramel apple hot toddy recipe the next time you have friends coming over. I guarantee everyone will love the amazing flavours in every sip. Bottoms up!
Other Recipes to Try
Bella Bucchiotti
Bella Bucchiotti is a Canadian-based syndicated food, travel, and lifestyle writer, photographer, and creator at xoxoBella. She founded xoxoBella in 2015, where she shares her love for food, dogs, sustainability, fitness, crafts, outdoor adventures, travel, and philanthropy to encourage others to run the extra mile, try new recipes, visit unfamiliar places, and stand for a cause. Bella creates stress-free and family-friendly recipes for weeknight dinners and festive feasts.
That toffee apple cider hot toddy is incredible! It’s my go-to drink for fall nights!
This was so good! We enjoyed it after a swim party!
Nearly too pretty to drink but they tasted so good! Not a drop was left 🙂
This is my kind of drink! YUM!